About louisville courier journal

This author has not yet filled in any details.
So far louisville courier journal has created 451 blog entries.

Louisville Metro Police Chief Erika Shields is stepping down

By |2022-11-21T15:28:36-05:00November 21st, 2022|Breonna Taylor, David McAtee|

Louisville Mayor-elect Craig Greenberg announced Monday that Erika Shields is resigning as Louisville Metro Police chief on Jan. 2, when the new administration takes office and Mayor Greg Fischer wraps up his third and final term.Greenberg said Shields offered to resign over the weekend after meeting with him and that he would accept her resignation. His new administration takes over Jan. 2, and he said he would select an interim chief before then, with plans to also pick a permanent chief to lead LMPD.Greenberg made his announcement at a news conference at the Preston Pointe office building on Main Street in downtown Louisville, and Shields was not there. Greenberg added that he expects to work with a search firm on the interim and permanent chief positions, welcoming applicants both locally and nationally to seek the top job at LMPD.Asked if Shields gave an explanation for her resignation or whether he asked Shields to remain in charge, Greenberg declined to share "all the details of our private conversation.""I want to thank Chief Shields for her service to our city, and I appreciate her willingness to remain on board to help with our transition," Greenberg said. "A search for a new chief of police will begin immediately. We will consider all applicants. I will seek the input of those on my transition as well as other folks from around our entire community."Who serves with Mayor Craig Greenberg?Here are 5 key roles Louisville Mayor-elect Craig Greenberg must fill in Jefferson County"When new mayors begin their term in Louisville and across the whole country, it is typical, I would say, for new chiefs to come on board," Greenberg also said. "So this is an opportunity for our city, for our police, for our city government, for all of us to move in a new direction."As for attributes in a police chief, Greenberg said he wants "someone who is respected by our entire community and the LMPD officers.""Second, the chief needs to be an individual who really values transparency," he continued. "Third, someone who is focused on community policing to prevent crime from happening. And fourth, the chief of police should have a strong engagement with folks throughout the entire community that are working to reduce the amount of poverty and crime through many different strategies."In an emailed statement shortly after the announcement, Shields said she looks forward to continuing to lead the department through the end of Fischer's administration."I am honored to have led the dedicated and talented officers of the Louisville Metro Police Department during a time of unprecedented change in policing here and across the country," Shields said. "Thank you to Mayor Greg Fischer for his trust in me and my team. I am proud to have served this Department as it worked to implement more than 150 reform efforts, a police salary increase to attract and retain the best and brightest, and, most importantly, a reduction in violent crime."Shields became chief in January 2021 following Fischer's firing of former Chief Steve Conrad in June 2020 as the city saw nightly racial justice protests in the wake of the police killing of Breonna Taylor. In the roughly six months before she came on board, the department was led by two different interim chiefs. She became Louisville's second female and first openly gay police chief, with Fischer praising her at the time of her hire as an "experienced, progressive, reform-minded leader."Fischer fired Conrad, who had an eight-year tenure as chief, after learning officers did not have their body cameras turned on during the fatal shooting of beloved BBQ chef David McAtee in the West End, a deadly incident that occurred in the early days of the 2020 protests over the police killings of Taylor, George Floyd and other Black Americans. In a statement, Fischer said he was "deeply appreciative" of Shields' service."At an incredibly challenging time, she came to Louisville and led an LMPD focused on reform and violent crime reduction, and in just the past year we see the results of that work – homicides down by nearly 14% and shootings are down 30%. Thank you to Chief Shields, her team, and her family – we are better off for their sacrifice and commitment."Shields repeatedly announced her commitment to decreasing violent crime, and leaders have said Louisville's renewed emphasis on funding violence prevention programs, implementing the Group Violence Intervention initiative (which both of the mayoral contenders said they support) and utilizing gun-tracing technology from the federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives are helping limit the bloodshed. More:Louisville's police force is short hundreds of officers. What's keeping applicants awayBut still, the city has continued to suffer record levels of homicides and shootings, with 184 criminal homicides in 2021, preceded by 165 in 2020, per LMPD data. As of early November, the city has seen over 140 homicides and over 370 nonfatal shootings this year. LMPD data shows a drastic decrease in nonfatal shootings as well, down about 33% compared to this time last year.Still, this year's homicide and nonfatal shooting totals are once again surpassing or likely to finish higher than the pre-pandemic period, when Louisville saw 93 homicides and nearly 400 nonfatal shootings in 2019. LMPD also has been struggling a massive officer shortage that has led to gaps in when and how officers have been responding to a number of scenes. For instance, the department's domestic violence unit was cut by nearly seven detectives under Shield's leadership.The staffing changes were made because "in 2021 the department was facing an unprecedented number of homicides and its staffing was at historical lows," spokeswoman Angela Ingram said. "Difficult personnel decisions had to be made to curb the steady occurrence of gun violence."More:'Decision that will cost lives': Domestic violence-related deaths spiked after LMPD cutsShields had stepped down as Atlanta's police chief in June 2020 after an officer fatally shot Rayshard Brooks. LMPD noted on its website during her time in Atlanta, the Georgia city saw "a reduction in violent crime and a marked increase in illegal gun seizures."While in the Peach State's capital city, Shields worked a wide array of assignments, including plainclothes work focused on narcotics, robbery investigations, internal affairs and accreditation for the Atlanta Police Department, with a focus on its technology, budget, training academy and recruitment. She also oversaw the patrol division.Shields is set to earn over $238,000 in 2022, according to the online Louisville Metro salary lookup site. A new chief will take charge at an important time for Louisville's police department. Greenberg said earlier this month he has not received any updates apart from what has been publicly reported on the Department of Justice's pending pattern-or-practice investigation into LMPD and Metro Government. Metro Council President David James, D-6th District, who is also serving on Greenberg's transition team, said Monday he "is thankful Chief Shields came to Louisville when she did."“She was a breath of fresh air and a very administratively sound police chief,” James told The Courier Journal in a text message. “Most new mayors want to have their own police chief, so this move shouldn’t be shocking to anyone.”This story has been updated.Reach Billy Kobin at [email protected]

Louisville reaches $2 million settlement with Kenneth Walker, Breonna Taylor’s boyfriend

By |2022-11-16T15:35:42-05:00November 16th, 2022|Breonna Taylor|

Louisville Metro settled with Breonna Taylor's boyfriend, Kenneth Walker, for $2 million on Monday, according to one of the parties who had been sued more than two years ago.Former Louisville Metro Police Sgt. Jonathan Mattingly, who was shot in the thigh by Walker as police burst through the door the night of the raid at Taylor's apartment, confirmed the settlement to The Courier Journal and said he and the other individual officers named in two civil lawsuits were released from having to pay.Frederick Moore, an attorney representing Walker, said he couldn't confirm the settlement or comment on the specifics of Monday's federal court mediation until "details have been finalized." City officials haven't yet responded to The Courier Journal's request for more information.Joey Klausing, an attorney representing former LMPD Detective Kelly Goodlett, said his client was released from the lawsuit Monday with no payment requirement. Goodlett in August pleaded guilty to a federal civil rights charge for her role in falsifying information used to obtain the search warrant on Taylor's apartment.Walker and Taylor, a 26-year-old unarmed Black woman, were asleep in her South End apartment on March 13, 2020 when LMPD officers attempted to serve a search warrant as part of a narcotics investigation. Walker, who has said he thought an intruder was breaking in, fired a single shot that hit Mattingly. Taylor was shot to death when police returned fire.Wednesday headlines:Mitch McConnell reelected as Senate GOP leader despite Sen. Rick Scott's challengeIn September 2020, Walker filed civil lawsuits in both state and federal court seeking punitive and compensatory damages against the city and several officers involved with the raid. It's not yet clear if the settlement also satisfies the lawsuit filed in state court.Walker's claims assert his rights were violated when officers obtained and approved the "materially false" search warrant, failed to announce before they entered Taylor's apartment and used excessive and unreasonable force. He also claims LMPD's policies, customs and practices led to these violations.Walker was charged with assault and attempted murder of a police officer in the immediate aftermath of the shooting, but those charges were dismissed permanently in March 2021.Walker's civil suits named Goodlett, former detective Joshua Jaynes and former Sgt. Kyle Meany for their purported role in falsifying and covering up the bad information used to obtain the warrant. All three were charged with federal civil rights violations in August.Read more:Kentucky Supreme Court elects next chief justice as John D. Minton heads toward retirementGoodlett resigned from LMPD following the indictment. She admitted in her plea to falsely claiming a Shively postal inspector verified Taylor was receiving packages for her ex-boyfriend, convicted drug dealer Jamarcus Glover, at her apartment before the raid. Glover was the subject of the narcotics investigation that resulted in Taylor's death. Goodlett told investigators she met with Jaynes in his garage so they could "get on the same page" after a postal inspector said the claim was bogus, and Meany allegedly had knowledge of the false claim.Also named in Walker's lawsuits are former officers Myles Cosgrove, who shot at Taylor 16 times and was fired by LMPD for failing to identify a target, Brett Hankison, whose return gunfire went into Taylor's neighbor's apartments, and Mattingly, who also returned fire at Walker. Hankison also faces federal charges for violating the civil rights of Taylor, Walker and three of Taylor's neighbors.This story will be updated.

‘Sacred Stories’: Here’s your complete guide to the 2022 Festival of Faiths

By |2022-11-15T14:33:29-05:00November 15th, 2022|Breonna Taylor|

What does your story say about you?  Find out at the 26th Festival of Faiths, Nov. 9-12 at the Kentucky Center, 501 W. Main St. This year's theme is "Sacred Stories: Contemplation and Connection," a look at how stories define our lives, give us purpose and make us feel part of something bigger. "It is through stories and the sharing of stories that we experience our humanity," said Sarah Riggs Reed, managing director of the Center for Interfaith Relations, which sponsors the event. "And this year at the festival we explore the power of narratives to change people, to move people, to deepen their sense of value, purpose, worth. Stories shape our identities and shared stories shape our communities."Here's what to know about the 2022 Festival of Faiths:What is the Festival of Faiths?Since its inception in 1996, the Festival of Faiths "has promoted interfaith understanding, cooperation and action while celebrating the timeless wisdom contained in the diversity of the world's faith traditions. The nationally acclaimed festival features meaningful dialogue with renowned spiritual leaders, thinkers, practitioners and artists," according to a news release announcing the event.To better understand a person's association with religion, culture, politics, heritage and other things that influence our identities, the festival investigates ancient and modern stories through the lens of faith. During the Festival of Faith sessions over three days, participants take part in storytelling activities that highlight individuality, while establishing a common bond with the rest of the group. More:Gerth: Why are so many Catholic churches closed in Black neighborhoods? It's a sinful storyNajeeba Syeed, a professor of interfaith studies, Muslim scholar and activist who will be presenting at the festival, said there is a constant overlap between religion and aspects of our identity."I think religion can be a part of someone's identity formation, one of many factors that form a whole human being," she said. "It’s not the only factor. Culture, national origin, even which neighborhood you grew up in form your identity. It is helpful to hear from people how religion played a role in their identity, instead of defining that for them."Who organized the Festival of Faiths?The Center for Interfaith Relations, one of the most distinctive religious organizations in the country, sponsors recurring events throughout the United States, including the Festival of Faiths.This Louisville-based festival attracts visitors from various religious backgrounds, promoting conversation and the acceptance of the religious beliefs of others.“The work of the Center (for Interfaith Relations) here in Louisville attempts to expand and deepen our understanding of religious neighbors near and far," said Dr. Lewis Brogdon, director of the Institute for Black Church Studies and associate professor of preaching and Black church studies. "The center also creates a space to celebrate the ways we are both similar and different."What is the 2022 theme of the Festival of Faiths?According to Riggs Reed, the "Sacred Stories: Contemplation and Connection," theme arose from the pandemic and the murder of Breonna Taylor. Riggs Reed believes the turmoil Louisville experienced in 2020 led a lot of people to examine their life stories and ask what narratives they accept and which ones they reject.More:Historic Baptist church's new co-pastor, a gay man, says calling is 'the honor of my life'"This year's [Festival of Faiths] starts the day after midterm elections," she said. "My hope is that this year, in particular, people will come together at the festival, celebrating the fact that we have so much more in common than what separates us. ... My hope is that people leave the festival convinced of the value of their own sacred story, ready to exchange stories with neighbors in new ways. ..."What events are taking place at the Festival of Faiths?Numerous events are taking place over the course of the three-day festival. It begins with the free Interfaith Opening Celebration on Nov. 9 from 5:30-7 p.m at the Cathedral of the Assumption, 433 S. 5th St. Reverend Shelton J. Fabre, archbishop of the Archdiocese of Louisville, will speak and singer-songwriter Carrie Newcomer will perform.From Nov. 10-12, a variety of ticketedworkshops will be held that include a diverse group of nearly 24 participants, including an expert in meditation, an Indigenous community organizer, an Old Testament scholar to a media analyst, Afrofuturist performer storäe michele and a priest.More:How Louisville football linebacker Yasir Abdullah's faith as a Muslim has shaped himHere is the list of events:Diverse Spiritual PracticesLessons of Old Stories in a New Context Changing Story Keepers: Millennials and Gen Zers An Evening of Sacred StorytellingThy Neighbor: Faith, Politics and Radical AcceptanceThe Sacred Stories That Connect UsSignificant Stories for Our Times: A Workshop with Matthew FoxShifting the Narrative: Transforming Hearts and Minds to Deepen Spiritual LifeFaith and a New Louisville Think-InA blood drive will also take place on Nov. 11 from 11 a.m. to 5 p.m. at the Muhammad Ali Center, 144 N. 6th St."I am honored to be presenting with Lyla June and Najeeba Syeed, as we explore important and radical shifts in storytelling," michele told the Courier Journal. "More specifically, we will discuss the ways these stories transform our lens of social justice and are connected to rising and future generations of communities for change."During the session titled "Changing Story Keepers: Millennials and Gen Zers," michele will perform a portion of her choreopoem and solo performance titled mama [rose.], which tells the experiences of a non-binary individual named Sid. Sid and their trans grandmother, Mama Rose, an archaeologist, embark on a journey seeking to heal intergenerational trauma.How much are tickets to the Festival of Faiths?Festival of Faith passes and individual session tickets can be purchased online at kentuckyperformingarts.org, by phone at 502-584-7777, or at the Kentucky Center box office. Passes for the entire festival are $200. Tickets for individual events are $29.95, which includes taxes and fees.The festival will also be live-streamed on theFestival of Faiths YouTube channel. COVID-19 restrictions will be in place and masks will be required when not actively eating or drinking.For more information, visit FestivalofFaiths.org.You can reach Culture and Diversity Reporter Jason Gonzalez at [email protected]. Follow him on Twitter @JayGon15NYC.

What’s next for the abortion fight in Kentucky after Constitutional Amendment 2’s defeat?

By |2022-11-10T10:32:27-05:00November 10th, 2022|Breonna Taylor|

Hours after voters rejected a measure known as Constitutional Amendment 2 to eliminate abortion rights from the Kentucky Constitution, opponents who worked to defeat it took a few minutes Wednesday to reflect on the victory − and look ahead."We know that Amendment 2 will not restore abortion access in Kentucky overnight," said Rachel Sweet, who managed the Protect Kentucky Access campaign against the measure. "But it is an important step in continuing the legal fight for abortion access in this state."Abortion has been illegal in Kentucky, except in medical emergencies, since the U.S. Supreme Court on June 24 struck down Roe v. Wade, eliminating the nearly 50-year-old federal right to abortion. Kentucky was among about a dozen states with a "trigger law" to immediately ban abortion in the event of such a ruling.Now abortion rights advocates are turning their attention to a pending court challenge to the law, a challenge that could have been rendered moot had the constitutional amendment passed.Kentucky Amendment 2:Opponents of Kentucky abortion amendment celebrate its defeatInstead, the Kentucky Supreme Court on Nov. 15 will hear arguments that the Kentucky Constitution provides a right to abortion. Lawyers for the state's two abortion providers are asking the court to allow abortion services to resume while a challenge to the trigger law and a second law banning abortions after six weeks works its way through the state court system.Jefferson Circuit Judge Mitch Perry in a preliminary ruling in July, found that the state constitution did appear to contain abortion rights, based on privacy, due process, equal protection and other provisions, and allowed abortion services to resume until the case was decided. But that ruling was blocked by a judge on the state Court of Appeals and no abortion services have been permitted until the Supreme Court hears the case and issues a ruling."We are very hopeful that our state lawsuit will ultimately restore abortion access in the commonwealth," said Jackie McGranahan, with the American Civil Liberties Union of Kentucky, whose lawyers are involved in the case.Kentucky Attorney General Daniel Cameron, an anti-abortion Republican, said he is ready to defend the two laws before the Supreme Court and has filed briefs arguing that the General Assembly, not the courts, is charged with making laws affecting abortion.In recent years, the GOP-controlled legislature has enacted more than dozen bills meant to ban or restrict access to abortion.Kentucky was among five states with abortion measures on the ballot Tuesday. California, Michigan and Vermont voters approved adding abortion rights to their state constitutions while a Montana ballot measure to ban some procedures remained pending as of Wednesday.Cameron, in a statement, said he was disappointed in the defeat of Kentucky's amendment."While this result is disappointing, it does not change our belief that there is no right to abortion hidden in the Kentucky Constitution and that the regulation of abortion policy is a matter that belongs with our elected representatives in the General Assembly," he said.That's the same argument more than two dozen GOP lawmakers made Oct. 27 at a news conference where they denounced alleged "misinformation" about the amendment, arguing it merely preserved the rights of members of the General Assembly, rather than judges, to make abortion laws."This amendment makes it clear that there is no right to abortion in the Kentucky Constitution," said Rep. Nancy Tate, R-Brandenburg and chairwoman of the legislators' "pro-life caucus." "This will keep state judges in their lane of interpreting the law and not inventing new laws and new rights that the constitution doesn't speak of."Kentucky election results:3 key takeaways from Kentucky's midterm election resultsTate also is among lawmakers who say they do not support exemptions in cases where a pregnancy results from rape or incest − which opponents to the amendment had criticized as unduly harsh."Some of my best friends were conceived through rape and incest," she said. "It absolutely breaks their heart when they hear from a public position that their life is not valued."But Sweet said she believes the defeat of the amendment sends a strong message to lawmakers that a majority of voters understood and rejected it."I think this does send a message to Kentucky lawmakers that they do not have carte blanche to pass whatever extreme abortion restrictions they choose," Sweet said.Further, Sweet said, some lawmakers, as well as other supporters of the amendment, have made it clear they oppose abortion in almost all circumstances including in cases of rape, incest or fetal anomalies."I think perhaps where they went wrong is being very clear about what their agenda is," Sweet said.Sen. Whitney Westerfield, a Crofton Republican, said in October that he personally does not support exemptions for abortions."This is really a reliigous and faith question for me," he said. "I don't believe we have the right to kill an innocent life God created."Wednesday, he said he was disappointed in the outcome of the amendment vote but said he doesn't believe it was a "fair fight," with opponents raising millions more dollars than supporters. Nor does he agree the vote sends a message to lawmakers."That assumes the people of Kentucky were informed fairly and correctly, and they weren't," Westerfield said.Both sides traded accusations of misleading or false claims about the amendment.Abortion opponents, while acknowledging they lost the battle over the constitutional amendment, say they remain committed to continuing the fight in court and elsewhere."The overturning of Roe v. Wade showed us how much work remains to protect the right to life in Kentucky and across the country," said Addia Wuchner, executive director of Kentucky Right to Life. "We are ready to do that work.Lawmakers could reintroduce the constitutional amendment next year, which would put it on the 2024 general election ballot. But Westerfield said, "I'm not aware if we'll do that."More politics:Judge who signed the warrant to search Breonna Taylor's apartment loses reelection bidWesterfield, who has sponsored several bills to restrict abortion, said he's calling on abortion opponents to do more to promote efforts to help pregnant women and make it less likely for them to seek abortions by aiding pregnancy crisis centers or other such programs."I think we can do more than any law can do," he said. "It's my hope that the pro-life community won't give up. ... We'll continue to deal with it and protect life as best we can."Contact reporter Deborah Yetter at [email protected] or on Twitter at @d_yetter.

Grandmaster Jay, militia leader who marched in Louisville, sentenced to 7+ years in prison

By |2022-11-09T14:33:51-05:00November 9th, 2022|Breonna Taylor|

The leader of a Black militia that marched through Louisville two times during the 2020 protests will spend several years behind bars on charges that he'd pointed a rifle at law enforcement officials more than two years ago.John Johnson, also known as Grandmaster Jay, was sentenced Wednesday to seven years and two months in prison after being found guilty of assaulting and brandishing a firearm towards state and federal officers on the eve of the 2020 Kentucky Derby, according to a statement from the U.S. Department of Justice. Johnson, 59, had initially been indicted by a federal grand jury in February 2021 and subsequently found guilty in May of this year.Aside from his prison sentence, Johnson will also have to serve 3 years of supervised release, with no option of parole, according to the release.A Cincinnati-area resident, Johnson came to Louisville on Sept. 4, 2020, with the militia group he leads, the "Not F------ Around Coalition," to participate in protests over the police killing of Breonna Taylor, a 26-year-old Black woman shot by Louisville Metro Police officers serving a no-knock warrant at her apartment in March 2020.Related:Questions surround Black militia leader John 'Grandmaster Jay' Johnson who had home in West ChesterDuring his time in Louisville that September – his second trip to the city following a demonstration earlier in the summer – Johnson was accused of pointing his AR-15 rifle toward a roof where an FBI agent, a Secret Service agent and three LMPD officers had been stationed, according to a federal complaint, which said the officers were "blinded by a light which they shortly thereafter determined was a flashlight mounted to the rifle being aimed at them by Johnson."Johnson was later found guilty of one count of assaulting a federal officer and one count of brandishing a firearm in relation to a crime of violence, with the Department of Justice arguing he'd "forcibly assaulted, resisted, opposed, impeded, intimidated, and interfered with a federally deputized task force officer who was performing official duties" at the time of the incident.An attorney listed as having represented Johnson did not immediately reply to a request for comment.2022 elections:Judge who signed the warrant to search Breonna Taylor's apartment loses reelection bidReach reporter Ana Rocío Álvarez Bríñez at [email protected].

Judge who signed the warrant to search Breonna Taylor’s apartment loses reelection bid

By |2022-11-09T12:31:07-05:00November 9th, 2022|Breonna Taylor|

Jefferson Circuit Judge Mary Shaw said in 2020 that she received death threats after signing the warrant for the police search in which Breonna Taylor was killed. Now the incumbent judge has lost her reelection. Shaw was narrowly defeated Tuesday by attorney Tracy Evette Davis, 51% to 49%. Shaw was the only incumbent circuit judge to draw a challenger, and lawyers outside the race said she was vulnerable because of her role in the Taylor case, in which the 26-year-old woman was shot and killed by police after her boyfriend fired one shot out of her apartment, thinking the couple was being robbed. It hit a detective in the leg and he and other detectives returned fire, killing Taylor. "I was disappointed by the results, but not surprised as there are so many false narratives surrounding the signing of the warrant which have circulated," Shaw said Wednesday. "I’m proud of the campaign I ran, and of the 16 years I have been on the bench.  It has been an honor and privilege.  I’ll be retiring from the state after 33 years of service and am looking forward to a new chapter."Kentucky election 2022:3 key takeaways from Kentucky's midterm election resultsShaw initially was criticized, accused of rubber stamping warrants for five raids on the night Taylor was killed, but two detectives who obtained them were indicted in August for lying on the affidavit used to get the warrant and a sergeant was charged with covering that up. One of the detectives, Kelly Goodlett, pleaded guilty and is expected to testify next year at the trial of former Detective Joshua Jaynes and Sgt. Kyle Meany, both of whom were fired.  Goodlett admitted she falsely claimed a postal inspector had verified Taylor was receiving packages for her ex-boyfriend, convicted drug dealer Jamarcus Glover, at her apartment before the raid. In fact, postal inspectors said there was no evidence Taylor was receiving packages at her apartment. Two attorneys, Davis and Christine Miller, filed to run against Shaw in the May primary but would not say if they challenged her because of the Taylor case. Miller finished third in the primary.  Miller finished third but Davis defeated Shaw Tuesday by a margin of 51-49. Neither Davis nor Shaw immediately responded to a request for comment. 

Women dominate Jefferson County judge races in 2022 election

By |2022-11-08T23:42:05-05:00November 8th, 2022|Breonna Taylor|

Women continued to dominate judicial elections on Tuesday in Jefferson County, where candidates vied in 16 contested races. Men won only one of the five races in which a male faced a female − with Anthony Jones defeating Emily Monarch.That continues a trend in which men are “pretty close to extinction” as one judge proclaimed after elections four years ago left only eight men – out of 40 − on the bench.More:Midterm election: Kentucky Sen. Rand Paul defeats Democrat Charles Booker.Here are the other results from Tuesday, in which four of five incumbents retained their seats.In one of two Court of Appeals contests, District Judge Annette Karem, who was trying to jump up two notches on the court ladder, defeated McKenzie Cantrell, a state representative.In the other appellate contest, Circuit Judge Audra Eckerle defeated Tricia Lister, who had less name recognition. None of the four candidates were endorsed by Citizens for Better Judges (CBJ), while the local chapter of Showing up for Racial Justice (SURJ) backed Cantrell and Lister. In an intriguing race for circuit court, District Judge Julie Kaelin, a progressive who opposes cash bail and was backed by SURJ, handily beat Ebert Haegele, an assistant commonwealth’s attorney who was endorsed by CBJ. More:Kentucky judge, hit with 45 ethics violations in July, is ordered removed from the benchIn another circuit contest that was followed closely, incumbent Mary Shaw, who signed the warrant for the police search that led to Breonna Taylor’s death, was defeated by Tracy Evette Davis, despite a recent report that she had a conviction in 2019 for reckless and drunken driving. In the three other circuit races: Ted Shouse, an outspoken criminal defense lawyer, lost to Melissa Bellows, who practices civil and criminal law.Sarah Clay, who was endorsed by both CBJ and SURJ, defeated Nichole Compton, who has both JD and MBA degrees. Patricia “Tish” Morris, who was trying to follow in the footsteps of her late father, Geoffrey Morris, a former circuit court judge, beat Dorislee Gilbert, a former assistant commonwealth's attorney and an advocate for domestic violence victims. In district court races: Anthony Jones, a former assistant public advocate in Henderson and an assistant county attorney in Jefferson County, beat the male jinx by defeating Emily Monarch.More:KY judge dismisses lawsuit blaming Louisville Bail Project in 17-year-old girl's deathKristina Garvey, the incumbent, beat Kelly Bowles, who in a campaign bio described herself as a public school teacher and a “proud member of the LGTBQ+ community.” Yvette de la Guardia, a former public defender, defeated Lora Holman, who has been a solo practitioner and who grew up in Oldham County.Incumbent Lisa Langford easily beat challenger Justin C. Brown, a former public defender. Megan McDonald, a lawyer and mediator − and the daughter of former Judges Tom and Dee McDonald − defeated Shanner Fauver, who was endorsed by SURJ. Karen Faulkner, a former public defender who ran unsuccessfully for county attorney in 2014, and who was endorsed by CBJ, beat Jessica Stone, an assistant county attorney, single mom and former ballet dancer. Incumbent Tanisha Hickerson, who was endorsed by CBJ, trounced challenger Kaitlin Dean, a Kansas native who described herself as a military spouse and an “impartial servant leader.” The daughter of Jefferson Circuit Clerk David Nicholson, Sara Micheal Nicholson, who was elected to District Court in 2016 after practicing law only two years and was deemed unqualified by 81% of lawyers in a Louisville Bar Association poll, walloped Christian Garrison, a former public defender and assistant county attorney. Mary Jue Wolford, who began her career as an assistant U.S. attorney in the Western District of New York, when her husband Will played for the NFL’s Buffalo Bills, and was later an assistant Jefferson County attorney, easily beat Claudette Patton, one of the first women to clerk for famed criminal defense attorney Frank Haddad and later a law clerk for federal Judge Charles Allen and a deputy attorney general who also practices in private law firms and taught for several universities. 

This circuit judge candidate’s courtroom experience includes stints as a defendant

By |2022-11-04T12:46:12-04:00November 4th, 2022|Breonna Taylor|

In her campaign for Jefferson Circuit Court, Tracy Evette Davis says she has practiced law for eight years all across the state of Kentucky.  But in addition to representing others, she was herself the defendant in at least three cases.The Courier Journal reviewed Davis' record after a judge not involved in the election on Wednesday questioned her qualifications.On Sept. 2, 2019, records show she was charged with reckless driving and driving under the influence – at 6:59 in the morning − after a deputy sheriff saw her “swerving all over the road” and “crossing all lanes” on Interstate 71.She failed three field sobriety tests given to her by a Louisville Metro Police officer, according to her citation.Asked about the charge, Davis said in an email, “We are all human.”She pleaded guilty but was placed in diversion, which she completed this July, resulting in her plea being set aside and dismissed, said Josh Abner, a spokesman for the county attorney’s office.He said she qualified for diversion because it was her first offense and because there were no “aggravating factors,” such as injuries or property damage.“I received no special privilege,” she said. “No one is above the law, myself included.”Also in 2019, Davis, now 43, was charged with a felony for “making a false statement to receive benefits,” when she applied for food stamps and Medicaid, according to court records. The records say her statement allowed her to receive a combined $15,909 in overpayments.But Abner said the charge was dismissed the next year when she was allowed to amend her tax return to show she had less income, which in turn qualified her for the benefits. Davis said she had not taken deductions in previous years to which she was entitled.In her email, Davis also noted that while the felony was charged in 2019, she was initially cited in 2013, when she was a single mother of three and studying for the bar exam.“I struggled like most families in Jefferson County and I am not ashamed of that,” she said.Davis was also sued in 2019 by a woman who provided management services for her unsuccessful 2018 campaign for district court and who alleged she failed to pay a $22,000 bill. When the sheriff’s office attempted to serve her with the suit six times at her home, Davis avoided service each time, according to court records.Steavon Deonna Stokes, the plaintiff, eventually won a default judgment against Davis, which she appealed, saying she had never been served with the lawsuit.  In a 2021 unanimous decision, the Court of Appeals affirmed the judgment.In her email, Davis said: “I dispute the facts in that case and unfortunately there was a default judgment for a company that never existed in the state of KY and was dissolved in Alabama in bad standing.”The Courier Journal was unable to locate anyone with the plaintiff’s name for comment.Her opponent, incumbent Jefferson Circuit Judge Mary Shaw, declined to comment for this story.Shaw was the only incumbent circuit judge in Jefferson County to draw a challenger in this year's elections. Lawyers said she was vulnerable because she signed the warrant that led to the 2020 police search of Breonna Taylor's home in which she was fatally shot by a detective after her boyfriend − thinking the couple was being robbed − fired one shot that struck a detective in the leg.Activists initially criticized Shaw for signing the warrant, but more recently detectives who obtained it have been charged in federal court with falsifying an affidavit to obtain it.

It’s settled: Breonna Taylor protesters who blocked bridge to no longer stand trial

By |2022-10-26T17:56:19-04:00October 26th, 2022|Breonna Taylor|

The trial is off.Twelve days before Breonna Taylor protesters were expected to face a jury for blocking traffic on the Clark Memorial Bridge, prosecutors announced the remaining defendants had agreed to settle their cases.Jefferson District Judge Anne Haynie had approved combining cases for 26 protesters into one trial in August. And in the weeks since, each defendant has agreed to complete 20 hours of volunteer service in exchange for having their misdemeanor charges dismissed and expunged from their records.“We believe this was a just offer in recognition that the actions of these individuals could have placed members of our community, including themselves, in danger," Jefferson County Attorney Mike O'Connell said in a statement Wednesday.Background:Prosecutors want 26 Breonna Taylor protesters to be tried together. Is that even possible?O'Connell's office previously reviewed more than 1,000 arrests stemming from racial justice protests in 2020 and 2021 and dismissed 70% of them, according to a Courier Journal analysis. But it moved forward with more than 200 cases involving violence, threats of violence, property damage and road blocking — including the bridge protest on June 29, 2020.That day, protesters associated with Black Lives Matter Louisville used vehicles and "a makeshift wall" to block traffic on the passageway between downtown Louisville and Southern Indiana, according to court documents filed by assistant Jefferson County attorneys Rebecca Schroering and Lindsay Beets.The protesters carried a faux coffin with the message "Rest in Power" written on it, and they hung a large banner bearing Taylor's face from the side of the bridge, which was closed for more than three hours.More:Why most protesters arrested by Louisville police will never be convicted of a crimeLouisville Metro Police arrested a total of 44 people during the protest and charged each with obstructing a highway and disorderly conduct. The county attorney's office previously moved to dismiss the latter charge for all defendants.While racial justice advocates have called on the county attorney to drop all charges against protesters, attorney Ted Shouse, who represented several bridge demonstration defendants, said the settlements are a step in the right direction."I think it’s an acknowledgement by the county that this protest should not result in a criminal conviction," he said. "... They didn't say we'll agree to no jail time, which is pretty standard. Here, they're saying we're agreeing to not only no jail time, but if you do volunteer work, it will be set aside, dismissed and expunged."There's no reason to brand these people as people who've been convicted of crimes."The county attorney's office estimates 52 protest-related cases remain open, with 25 having pending court dates. Twenty-seven of the cases have bench warrants following a failure to appear in court.Reach reporter Bailey Loosemore at [email protected], 502-582-4646 or on Twitter @bloosemore. Support strong local journalism by subscribing today: https://www.courier-journal.com/baileyl.

Go to Top